All research

ESSAY 02 · METHOD · 7 MIN

The mathematics residential never had

Commercial property is valued three ways: what it earns, what it costs to replace, and what comparable assets sold for. Residential property, the largest asset most families will ever hold, gets one method. Comparables, read by a person with a sales target, on the asset you are about to hand them.

That struck us as absurd, so we built the triangulation: an income anchor, a cost anchor, and an honestly adjusted sales comparison, fused under a calibration derived from blind tests on real sales. When the anchors disagree, the disagreement itself is the finding. A market paying well above its income anchor is running on sentiment. A market priced near replacement cost is rational. Sellers deserve to know which market they are standing in.

“A market paying above its fundamentals is not strong. It is fragile. The spread tells you which.”

The results convinced us. Across twenty blind-tested sales, the model held its range 88.9% of the time at a 3.3% mean error, on a market moving fast enough that the RBA had hiked three times to 4.35% during the testing window. On the same houses, portal-grade automated estimates ran systematically high, in one documented case by $57,000. The black box is not evil. It is blind to what it cannot see: renovation quality, floor plans, streets. That blindness is where the money hides.

Sources

ALURA validation log: 20 blind backtest sales, Sep 2026 (88.9% containment, 3.3% mean error)

RBA cash rate decisions, 2026 (three consecutive hikes to 4.35%)

Comparative case: 29 Lisa Crescent, Coomera, sale price $943,000 vs AVM ~$1,000,000, Sep 2026

Standard property assessment methods: income, cost and direct comparison approaches (API practice standards)